Taste at Scale

On preparation, judgment, and why execution is now a commodity

10 min read

So I collect memorabilia from dead companies. I know how that sounds.

There's a shelf in my office—Theranos badge holder, WeWork coaster, Quibi notebook still in the plastic. And then under glass, because I'm a little precious about these: two Enron golf balls and a Lehman Brothers desk clock.

People see it and they don't know what to say. Which, fair.

But here's why. The Theranos stuff, the WeWork coaster—those are hubris artifacts. One founder, one company, one spectacular delusion. When Theranos collapsed, you could draw a line around the damage. It was contained.

Lehman's different. Lehman took everything with it. One rotten foundation connected to everything downstream, and when it gave way the whole system broke. Banks that had nothing to do with mortgages. Regular people with retirement accounts who thought they were diversified.

That's the failure that fascinates me. Not the isolated implosion—the contagion. When the foundation is wrong and everything built on it fails too.

I keep the Lehman clock under glass because it reminds me of something I don't want to forget.

Merriam-Webster named "slop" the word of the year. So did the American Dialect Society. So did The Economist.

And the discourse since has been predictable. Reject AI entirely. Produce less content. Add watermarks or disclaimers. Learn to live with the garbage.

None of it's serious. All of it misses the point.

Here's what bothers me: everyone's acting like AI invented slop. Like before ChatGPT we had this golden age of thoughtful, intentional marketing, and now the machines ruined it.

Come on.

Slop existed long before AI. It was just more expensive to produce.

I've been doing this for 14 years, most of it working with DTC brands—the ones past the scrappy phase, doing $15M, $50M, $100M, trying to figure out why the playbook that got them here stopped working.

My first agency was DBNY. And back then—before generative AI, before any of this—we'd start a rebrand or website project by asking clients for references. What do you like? What's inspiring you?

80% of them said Apple.

Every time. The minimalism. The white space. The confidence of saying very little and letting the product speak.

And look, I get it. Apple's great. But here's the thing: Apple can do that because they're Apple. Fifty years of brand equity. A product everyone already understands. They've earned the right to be minimal.

You're probably not Apple. Your customers probably don't know who you are yet. That minimalism that reads as confidence for them? For you it reads as "we couldn't figure out what to say."

That's slop. Pre-AI slop. Copying the visible output of a successful brand without understanding why it worked or whether it applies to you.

I've sat in a lot of rooms over 14 years. Watched people present creative work with the self-seriousness of a sommelier decanting a 1982 Lafite—swirling the strategy doc, letting it breathe, waiting for the room to appreciate the bouquet.

And then that same work disappears into the market without leaving a trace.

One room in particular. Midtown, winter, one of those buildings where the lobby costs more than most apartments. Beautiful deck. Client's nodding. And I'm looking at the customer segmentation slide—the personas, the journey maps—and I realize I have no idea where any of it came from. The segments had names and motivations and all the vocabulary of rigor. But underneath? Vibes. Assumptions in framework clothing.

Campaign launched. Executed flawlessly. Creative was genuinely good.

Landed with the thud of something precisely targeted at people who didn't exist.

Or this. DTC brand, $40M in revenue, email program with 40% open rates. Everyone's celebrating.

Which—unless you're tracking opens to diagnose a deliverability problem, stop doing that. Open rates don't tell you anything about business impact.

So opens are being heralded while finance is quietly noting that revenue hasn't moved. We dug into the customer file. Turns out the campaigns were hitting their most engaged subscribers hardest—customers who would've bought anyway. Marketing was successful. Business wasn't.

When we mapped acquisition source to two-year contribution margin, 40% of their "best" customers by engagement were actually underwater on a fully-loaded basis. The scoreboard was lying.

Nobody wanted to talk about it.

That's slop. Not because the work was ugly—a lot of it was gorgeous. It's slop because there's no intelligence behind it. No understanding of who it's for or whether it connects to anything that matters.

The content can be beautiful and still be slop.

AI didn't create this. AI just made it faster and cheaper.

I cook. Not professionally, but seriously—the way some people golf or fish. It's what I do when I need to think. Or stop thinking.

There's this concept in professional kitchens: mise en place. French for "putting in place." Everything prepped, measured, organized before you turn on the heat. Onions diced. Garlic minced. Spices measured out.

Amateurs skip it. They think cooking starts when the pan gets hot.

It doesn't. Cooking starts way before that. The mise is the foundation. Get it right and everything flows. Get it wrong and you're fighting chaos the whole time.

Most marketing has no mise.

Brands turn on the heat before they've even looked at what's in the fridge. They start executing—campaigns, content, whatever—without doing the foundational work of understanding who their customers actually are. Not personas. The actual customer file. Who bought, what they bought, whether they came back, what they're worth.

Every brief starts from zero. Nothing builds on anything.

That's how you get slop. Not from lack of effort—from lack of foundation.

Bill Belichick, defensive genius and the ultimate CEO-style head coach, used to say "discipline is consistent excellence." Not discipline as punishment, but discipline as the ability to execute well, repeatedly, under different conditions. Boring stuff done right, over and over and over again, until it compounds into something that looks like magic.

Most marketing has no discipline.

Not because people are lazy—they're usually working way too hard, producing more than ever while feeling less certain that any of it matters.

The dashboards show activity. Emails sent, ads served, impressions delivered.

Then you sit down with the CFO and they have different numbers. Revenue. Margin. The stuff that pays for things.

I've been in those meetings. Marketing scoreboard says you're winning. Finance scoreboard says you're not. The dissonance in the room is physical.

That's the slop gap.

There's a guy named Greg Cosell who breaks down NFL film. Been doing it for decades. What he does is show you the game beneath the game.

The broadcast shows the quarterback throwing a touchdown. Cosell shows you the protection that gave him time, the route that created the window, the pre-snap read that told him where to look.

Same play. Completely different understanding.

Broadcast makes it look like instinct and talent. Film shows you the system—preparation, structure, thousands of small decisions that made the moment possible. What looks like improvisation is usually architecture.

Marketing has the same gap.

That campaign that "worked"? Might've worked for reasons that have nothing to do with the campaign. Competitor outage. Random TikTok moment. Favorable timing. Dashboard says success. The why is a mystery.

That channel "underperforming"? Might be the only thing preventing collapse somewhere else.

You can't see this from the broadcast view. You have to watch the film.

The film, in marketing, is the customer file. Who they are, what they've done, what they're worth. Not personas. Not assumptions. Not the story you tell yourself because it's easier than looking at the data.

Most brands never watch the film.

There's this concept in probability called ergodicity. Sounds academic but the idea's simple.

What works on average across a population might not work for any individual in it.

The benchmarks. The best practices. The case studies. Those are population-level insights. What worked across a bunch of contexts, smoothed into something that looks like a roadmap.

And they get applied to individual brands as if the average were a guarantee. As if your customers were average customers.

Sometimes they are. Often they're not.

The playbook was right in general and wrong for you specifically. Which, if you're you, means it was just wrong.

This is where judgment matters. Knowing your own customers well enough to recognize when the average doesn't apply.

AI can't do this. AI's trained on the average—that's the whole point. Useful sometimes. Catastrophic others.

The slop flooding the internet is average thinking applied indiscriminately. Same frameworks, same voice, replicated infinitely because the marginal cost is zero.

When people say "taste" they usually mean aesthetics. Font pairings. Color palettes. The ineffable thing that separates good design from templates.

That's real. But it's not the taste that matters most.

The taste that matters is judgment.

Knowing which customers are actually valuable versus which just look good in a cohort analysis. Understanding when a program optimized for volume is destroying margin. Recognizing that the strategy everyone agrees on is the strategy no one's tested against reality.

Seeing what's actually happening—not what dashboards suggest—and making decisions based on that.

This is what AI can't automate. Not because the tech isn't good enough. Because this requires something upstream of execution: a point of view about what matters, built through experience.

Everyone has access to the same tools now. Same platforms, same models, same dashboards. Execution's a commodity.

What's scarce is the judgment to know what to execute.

That's taste at scale. Judgment operationalized. The only moat left.

Audience is the only asset that compounds.

Creative gets stale. What worked last year feels dated now.

Channels saturate. Algorithms change.

Tactics get copied. Your competitor hires someone who knows how to do it and suddenly your advantage is table stakes.

But understanding your customer file—who they are, what they've done, what they're worth—that appreciates. Every decision gets smarter. Every campaign builds on the last.

The work compounds instead of resets.

That's mise en place at scale. Foundation that turns execution into architecture.

Opposite of slop.

I should mention—as someone with roots in upstate New York—slop isn't always bad.

It's 2am in Rochester. You're at Nick Tahou's or one of the places that inherited the tradition. Fluorescent lights doing no one any favors. Guy in a Bills jersey who's been there since the game ended. Couple either on a first date going well or a last date going poorly. Cook who's worked this shift fifteen years.

Everyone's eating a Garbage Plate.

Home fries and macaroni salad, topped with meat, covered in hot sauce and onions. Looks like someone lost a bet.

It's also perfect.

Not despite being slop—because it's slop. It knows what it is. Not pretending to be fine dining. A 2am regional specialty that delivers exactly what it promises.

The people there—late-night regulars, post-game crowd—they're not being fooled. They're in on it.

The slop flooding the internet is the opposite. Pretending to be something it's not. Costume of insight without substance.

A Garbage Plate never pretends to be a tasting menu.

The content in your feed pretends to be thought leadership.

I'm still collecting, by the way.

Found a Juicero packet on eBay last month. Company raised $120 million for a $700 machine that squeezed juice from proprietary bags. Bags you could, as Bloomberg demonstrated, squeeze just as well with your hands.

Perfect artifact. Smart people, real money, elaborate system built on assumptions that didn't survive contact with reality.

It's on the shelf now. Next to the Theranos badge, the WeWork coaster, the Quibi notebook. Enron and Lehman stay under glass.

Foundations matter. When they're wrong, sometimes one company fails. Sometimes everything connected to it fails too.

The coaster outlasts the company.

The mise outlasts the improvisation.

The judgment outlasts the tools.

Taste at scale isn't about producing more beautiful content. It's about knowing who you're talking to well enough that what you produce actually matters.

That's why we start every engagement with the customer file, not the campaign brief. The mise before the heat.

Everything else is just slop.

Amlan Das Signature

Founder / El Capitan

Quarterly newsletter

New perspectives, launches, and moments — four times a year.